La Crosse Local

8 Thrift Stores and Vintage Shops for Your Halloween Costume

Halloween is right around the corner, and if you’re looking for a unique costume, La Crosse area local thrift stores and vintage stores have you covered! Thrifting is the perfect way to find pieces that can be transformed into a one-of-a-kind costume. With a little creativity and some thrift store magic, you can put together a fantastic look without breaking the bank. Plus, you’ll feel good knowing you’re reusing items and keeping things eco-friendly!


White Buffalo Thriftery

thift shops
White Buffalo Thriftery | photo by Emma Lonergan for La Crosse Local

Location: 500 Main Street, La Crosse

Hours: Wednesday – Saturday 11 am – 5 pm, Sun 11 am – 4 pm

In need of a fun hat, vintage clothing, or unique accessory to pull your look together? White Buffalo Thriftery has you covered! A wide-brimmed hat can turn you into a witch, and a quirky vintage necklace could be the finishing touch on a period costume. Often the best costumes are created by repurposing items in unexpected ways!

 


 

The Second Hand Shack Thift Store

thrift stores
The Second Hand Shack | photo by Emma Lonergan for La Crosse Local

Location: 2612 South Ave, La Crosse

Hours: Monday – Saturday, 9:30 am – 5:30 pm

We’re always welcoming a new thrift store in town! The Second Hand Shack is a great spot for both everyday thrifting and the annual Halloween costume search. What’s even better — a percentage of all the sales go to local nonprofits and veterans. Find your costume and give back!

 


 

Salvation Army Thrift Store 

thrift stores
Salvation Army Thrift Store | photo by Emma Lonergan for La Crosse Local

Location: 728 Copeland Ave, La Crosse

Hours:  Monday -Friday 9 am-  6 pm, Saturday 9 am – 5 pm

So many amazing finds at the Salvation Army Thrift Store! Think anything from shoes, headbands and hats, and even full costume sets. Shopping at the Salvation Army Store helps to combat homelessness in the area as proceeds from their sales support the programs and services at the Salvation Army Emergency Shelter.

 


 

The Wee Repeat Thrift Store

thrift stores
The Wee Repeat | photo by Emma Lonergan for La Crosse Local

Location: 1732 Market Street, La Crosse 

Hours: Tuesday – Friday 10 am-5 pm, Saturday 10 am – 3 pm

If you’re looking for your little ones, thrift stores are a great option for kids’ costumes too. You’ll often find gently used costumes from previous years, along with other kid-friendly clothing that can be transformed into classic characters like superheroes or animals. The prices are unbeatable at Wee Repeat! An extra win for this store too as they give back to the community. Biannually, Wee Repeat donates the remainder of their seasonal inventory to a local Children’s Closet, and stocks up the Little Free Libraries around the community with books!

 


 

Good Steward Resale Shop

thift stores
Good Steward Resale Shop | photo by Emma Lonergan for La Crosse Local

Location: 1930 Rose St, La Crosse

Hours: Tuesday 10 am  – 6 pm, Wednesday – Saturday 10 am – 5 pm

Thrift stores are full of random treasures—think outside the box! A retro jacket could make you a 90s throwback character, while a ruffled dress and accessories could turn you into a spooky Victorian ghost. With a little time and searching, you can mix and match pieces to create your own unique costume from the Good Steward Resale Shop. This store benefits the local Luther High School and many charities, so you can feel good about your shopping, too!

 


 

Thrifty Pickins’ & Buckies Thift Store

thrift stores
Thrifty Pickins & Buckies | photo by Emma Lonergan for La Crosse Local

Location: 980 WI-Hwy 16, West Salem

Hours: Monday – Saturday, 10 am – 6 pm

If you’re looking to venture outside of La Crosse a bit, make sure to check out Thrifty Pickins’ & Buckies! Racks and racks of clothes to sift through to find your perfect look. Thrifty Pickins’ & Buckies gives thousands back to community organizations, like local schools, the YWCA, Hunger Task Force, and many others. As their slogan says, giving back is always in style!

 


Singlestitch LAX

thift stores
Singlestitch LAX | photo courtesy of Singlestich LAX

Location: 123 4th St S, La Crosse

Hours: Thursday – Saturday, 12 pm – 8 pm, Sunday, 12 pm – 6 pm

Singlestitch Vintage is an amazing shop known for its curated selection of unique vintage clothing and accessories. With a focus on sustainability and individuality, the shop offers everything from retro tees to classic denim, perfect for those looking to express their personal style. Perfect if your Halloween costume is an old-school movie character or pop culture persona!

 


Goodwill

thrift stores
Goodwill | photo by Emma Lonergan for La Crosse Local

La Crosse Location: 3954 Mormon Coulee Rd

Onalaska Location: 200 Theater Rd

Hours: Monday – Thursday: 9 am – 8 pm, Sunday: 9 am-7 pm

Goodwill is a go-to spot for its diverse selection of gently used clothing and accessories, making it a prime spot to find costume components. If you’re not feeling overly creative, no worries – they also have an entire section of Halloween costumes ready to go!

Happy thrifting!

 


 

Looking for something to do in La Crosse? Check the La Crosse Local Events Calendar!

Related posts

La Crosse Guide to Thanksgiving Takeout and Dining

Emma Lonergan

La Crosse Guide to November Events

Becky Montpetit

Your Top Picks for Breakfast and Brunch in the La Crosse Area

Emma Lonergan